
This is a question that a woman emailed me after reading my post The Problem with Being Positive: “Can I harness my power and still be nice?”
The short answer is no.
Because, “power” is the ability to act effectively and create what matters most in your work and life. And what is “nice”?
Nice is a knife.
It’s a knife you use to cut off parts of your self that are unacceptable. You started using the knife when you were young. Cutting off the parts that don’t fit with family expectations. It’s something we all do. It’s part of the human condition. But, don’t worry; those dismembered parts of yourself are still part of you.
The dismembered parts don’t disappear.
They go into, what Robert Bly, evoking the work of C.G. Jung, called the “shadow bag”. All the cut off parts of your psyche go into the shadow bag. Here’s how it works . . .
Imagine you’re a kid feeling the buoyant energy of Spring.
You run into the living room whooping, leaping, and bouncing off the walls. You’re feeling pure joy. But, to your folks your behavior appears “noisy” and “crazy” and “loud”. They tell you in no uncertain terms to cut it out. And, you do.
You cut out the buoyant, leaping, energetic parts of yourself and stuff them onto the shadow bag.
Year by year the bag getting heavier, filled with the unacceptable parts of your life. The parts of your soul, psyche, and self and were deemed unacceptable by powerful “others” – parents, teachers, leaders, friends, lovers, etc.
Those parts aren’t gone. They’re in the shadow bag. You drag them behind you but don’t offer them to the world. You tip toe along. You modulate your voice. You’re nice.
Every cut diminishes your power.
You can still proceed with your life. Even with parts of cut off. You can even do quite well – you’re nice after all, and people respond well to nice. But, there’s that bag and all those cut off parts dragging behind you.
Sooner or later things start to stink.
You begin to notice a strange odor. At first it comes and goes. It’s bothersome but not persistent. But, if neglected for too long, the stink gets stronger. Soon, every meeting you go to, every conversation you have, everywhere you go, is permeated with that annoying odor.
It’s the odor of your cut off parts seeking to rejoin your life.
They’ve been reaching out to you all along. But, you were trained not to notice. So, you didn’t.
You were taught from a young age to hide your deepest longings, to deny essential and sacred parts of who you are. In your family, school, and at work you’ve been encouraged to act as if you are complete while simultaneously cutting of parts of your self and exiling them to the shadow bag.
When you cut off parts of yourself, you cut off the flow of your life.
To get your life moving in a powerful, authentic direction starts with reclaiming the parts of yourself that have been cut off. And reclaiming starts when you notice that persistent stink.
In the Gospel of Thomas, Jesus is quoted as saying “”If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you. If you do not bring forth what is within you, what you do not bring forth will destroy you.”
The stink that’s pursuing you isn’t a problem to make go away. It’s a call to live more fully and contribute more completely. Which all sounds great. But, honestly it’s not easy to face the stink.
So, before you face the stink of the shadow bag, you may want to try some air freshener.
You know what I mean? Maybe take vacation to recharge your batteries.
But, pay attention to what happens when you come back from vacation. If you find that within a day (an hour) of returning to the office that the stink has returned – be not deceived. The issue isn’t that you’re not getting enough time off.
Not that there’s anything wrong with a vacation.
There’s not. Same with exercise, yoga, meditation, and hiring a coach. All can be useful. But, if you use them to mask the stink and to avoid facing the shadow bag – you’re avoiding the issue. This issue is whether you want to be powerful or nice. To create what matters most or wield the knife of nice and cut more deeply into the your life.
Let me be the first to admit – I’d rather use air freshener than face my shadow bag.
I’d rather not face the stink. But, at a certain point, it becomes clear that turning towards the shadow bag is the way forward. The path to power travels through the shadow bag.
It’s not a matter of being either nice or being powerful.
It’s a matter of facing your experience fully. Truthfully. Without leaping to conclusions or solutions. It’s a matter of life.
So, how can you proceed? If you’re ready to be powerful, just, take the next step on the path of power. There’s really no road map. It’s a step-by-step process.
Step towards the unacceptable places within you.
You don’t need to do anything else. Simply step with awareness towards the shadow bag. Take your time.
As you step forward, your experience of the stink changes. You begin to see how the difficulties you encounter (especially the really stinky ones) are precisely structured to call forth the cut off parts that are waiting to be redeemed from your shadow bag.
The conflicts that you face at work and in life point towards the un-integrated parts of your self to return to life.
I don’t want you to think that this path is automatically strewn with flower petals. But, I do want to encourage you to pay attention. Notice the stink. Step forward. And keep breathing.
Yes, keep breathing and soon you’ll notice something strange. That stink – which had been so noxious – is starting to smell like flowers.
Now, that’s nice.

10 responses so far ↓
1 Barb // May 10, 2010 at 2:31 pm
Thank you so much for this one!
2 Eric // May 13, 2010 at 5:45 pm
Barb – you’re welcome. Thank you for your comment and appreciation.
3 UncommonJulie // May 18, 2010 at 7:09 pm
Great post! Nice is a knife. That will stick! Thank you.
4 Susanne Gunning // May 18, 2010 at 7:50 pm
Useful message, well communicated. I guess it’s about taking a closer look at your issues and not merely masking or bandaiding them.
5 Eric // May 20, 2010 at 9:33 pm
Yes, band-aids are delaying tactics at best,
Thank you for your comment,
E
6 Molly Gordon, Self-Employment Coach // May 29, 2010 at 5:56 pm
“Nice is a knife.”
This certainly casts a different light on my concern that I am not a nice person. That is, I realize I do kind things for others and that I care deeply about their well being. But I am generally unwilling to pretend that things are nicer than they are or that I am more satisfied than I am with the status quo.
Preoccupation with what is wrong doesn’t work, but preoccupation with covering up what is wrong may be even more damaging. Thank you for a provocative post.
7 Jennifer Louden // May 29, 2010 at 5:59 pm
But Eric, I love my stink. Next post, talk about being in love with your stink and using that to prove you are too stinky to be any good. Great post!
8 Sharon Kolker // May 29, 2010 at 11:10 pm
“Step toward the unacceptable place in yourself”. Love that! Great post, Eric!
9 WalterSaurous Rex... // Jun 13, 2010 at 1:15 am
What interests me is the line between “nice” and socially acceptable. When you migrate between many social and ethnic groups, one can become a little impatient with the current group’s idea of “nice”. If you let that show, folks will decide that you are not nice.
Walter C.
“Being nice will get you a whole lot further
than being right.” Bruce “U. Utah” Philips (My mentor, musician, labor organizer, social gadfly, high level genius, and very wise man.)
10 Eric // Jun 13, 2010 at 2:39 am
Yes it’s dancing on the edge (the line) that promotes both outer and inner harmony/growth.
Then, nice is service and sensitivity not suppression.
Leave a Comment